Some Bits: Nelson's weblog

Coding craft vs. AI

Do you care how your code is written? Or just that it works?

That’s the fundamental divide I see in all the angst around AI coding agents. LLMs write working code very quickly. But agent coding is undermining our culture of finely crafted software.

There’s a lot of stress in my software engineer community. Folks are exhausted trying to keep up with AI output, they’re worried about their jobs, they’re worried about the future. AI submissions are sucking the joy out of open source work, destroying the delicate culture of craftspeople working together on something they are proud of.

Does well crafted code have a future in a competition with AI agents? What does losing hand-written code cost us in code quality, æsthetics, training, or simple joy in our work?

I’m a technoptimist. These past two months with Claude Code have been incredibly productive and fun for me. I’ve built a lot of useful things for myself and am happy with how they work. I used to pride myself on being a very good crafter of code. But I’m OK giving that up and letting agents do the work for me. My expertise is still useful in making sure the AI builds systems in a reliable way. And I am having a lot of fun doing custom one-off systems. But I have a particularly retired-guy perspective. I’m grateful I’m not trying to make a living anymore doing high stakes work.

I wonder what we can learn from the history of mechanization of previous kinds of crafting and manufacturing?